
Walk-In Shower vs Tub, Side by Side
A walk-in shower and a tub fit the same alcove, but they work very differently day to day.
| Walk-in shower | Bathtub | |
|---|---|---|
| Getting in | Low curb or no curb at all | Step over a tub wall about 15 inches high |
| Daily use | Fast showers; room for a bench and a handheld | Baths for children and soaking; a combo also showers |
| Cleaning | Glass and tile to wipe down | A curtain or doors and the tub itself |
| Space | Feels larger, especially with clear glass | Takes the same alcove, but the room reads smaller |
| Safety | Bench and grab bars are easy to add | Climbing in and out is harder with age |
| Resale | Popular in primary baths | Buyers with young children often want one |
Getting in
- Walk-in shower
- Low curb or no curb at all
- Bathtub
- Step over a tub wall about 15 inches high
Daily use
- Walk-in shower
- Fast showers; room for a bench and a handheld
- Bathtub
- Baths for children and soaking; a combo also showers
Cleaning
- Walk-in shower
- Glass and tile to wipe down
- Bathtub
- A curtain or doors and the tub itself
Space
- Walk-in shower
- Feels larger, especially with clear glass
- Bathtub
- Takes the same alcove, but the room reads smaller
Safety
- Walk-in shower
- Bench and grab bars are easy to add
- Bathtub
- Climbing in and out is harder with age
Resale
- Walk-in shower
- Popular in primary baths
- Bathtub
- Buyers with young children often want one
When a Walk-In Shower Makes Sense
- No one takes baths: the tub only gets used as a shower.
- Getting in is harder: stepping over a tub wall is a strain for someone in the house.
- Planning ahead: you want a bathroom that works as you get older, with room for a bench and grab bars.
- Small room: a clear glass shower makes a small bathroom feel bigger than a tub with a curtain.
- Another tub exists: there is already a tub in another bathroom in the house.
For many Dallas homes, the tub to shower conversion happens in the primary bath, while the hall bath keeps its tub.
“Our primary bathroom had a cramped shower and a huge tub we almost never used. We remodeled the space around what we actually needed, and the new walk in shower has completely changed the room. The layout feels larger now without adding any square footage.”
When Keeping the Tub Makes Sense
- Young children: bathing small kids is far easier in a tub.
- Soaking matters: someone in the house takes baths for comfort or to relax.
- Only tub in the house: some buyers, families especially, will want one when you sell.
- Budget is tight: replacing a tub and surround in place usually costs less than building a new shower.
Keeping a tub does not mean keeping a bad one. A new tub with a tiled surround, a niche and a better valve can refresh a hall bath without changing the layout. See our small bathroom remodel service.
Cost: Walk-In Shower vs Tub
Keeping a tub is usually the cheaper path, because the drain and valve stay where they are. Converting to a walk-in shower costs more, mostly for the drain, the shower pan and the glass.
- Tub-and-shower combo remodel in Dallas
- $1,550 – $8,760
- Angi's Dallas average range
- Tub to shower conversion
- $2,000 – $12,000
- National range; most projects $5,000 – $10,000 (This Old House)
- New walk-in shower
- $4,000 – $20,000
- National range; typical project about $12,000 (This Old House)
Market ranges, not quotes from CM Bathroom Remodel Dallas. Sources listed at the end of this guide.
For a full breakdown, see our tub to shower conversion cost guide.
Safety for Older Adults
Bathrooms are a common place to get hurt. A CDC study of 2008 emergency room data estimated 234,094 nonfatal bathroom injuries among people 15 and older; 81% were falls, injury rates rose with age, and the highest rate was in or around the tub or shower.
A walk-in shower helps because it removes the high tub wall. A curbless shower goes further, with no step at all, and a built-in bench, a handheld shower and grab bars anchored into solid blocking make showering easier for anyone. In older neighborhoods like those in Duncanville and Richardson, this is a common reason to replace a tub.
Asked often
Walk-In Shower vs Tub Questions
Does removing a bathtub lower home value?
Not by itself. The concern is removing the only tub in the house, since some buyers want one for young children. If another bathroom keeps its tub, a walk-in shower in the primary bath is a common upgrade.
Can a small bathroom have both a tub and a walk-in shower?
Rarely. A tub and a separate shower usually need more space than a hall bath has. In a small bathroom, the choice is one or the other, or a tub with a shower over it.
Is a walk-in shower safer than a tub?
For most people, getting into a walk-in shower is easier than stepping over a tub wall, and a bench and grab bars are simple to add. A wet tile floor still needs slip-resistant tile and good drainage.
Does a walk-in shower need a door?
No. A fixed glass panel with an open entry works when the shower is deep enough to keep water in; a door or a second panel helps in a shorter shower.
Can you help me decide at the quote?
Yes. At the free in-home quote, we look at the bathroom, who uses it and the rest of the house, and price both options if you want to compare.
Sources
- Angi, Dallas, TX shower remodel cost page, accessed November 2026.
- This Old House, "How Much Does Tub-to-Shower Conversion Cost? (2026 Guide)", updated March 4, 2026.
- This Old House, "How Much Does a Walk-In Shower Cost? (2026 Guide)", updated October 7, 2026.
- CDC, "Nonfatal Bathroom Injuries Among Persons Aged ≥15 Years, United States, 2008", MMWR, June 10, 2011.